Supporting Argumentation Systems by Graph Representation and Computation
نویسندگان
چکیده
Argumentation is a reasoning model based on arguments and on attacks between arguments. It consists in evaluating the acceptability of arguments, according to a given semantics. Due to its generality, Dung’s framework for abstract argumentation systems, proposed in 1995, is a reference in the domain. Argumentation systems are commonly represented by graph structures, where nodes represent arguments and edges attacks between arguments. However beyond this graphical support, graph operations have not been considered as reasoning tools in argumentation systems. This paper proposes a conceptual graph representation of an argumentation system and a computation of argument acceptability relying on conceptual graph defaults.
منابع مشابه
Value-based Argumentation Frameworks as Neural-symbolic Learning Systems
While neural networks have been successfully used in a number of machine learning applications, logical languages have been the standard for the representation of argumentative reasoning. In this paper, we establish a relationship between neural networks and argumentation networks, combining reasoning and learning in the same argumentation framework. We do so by presenting a new neural argument...
متن کاملTowards a General Argumentation System based on Answer-Set Programming
Within the last years, especially since the work proposed by Dung in 1995, argumentation has emerged as a central issue in Artificial Intelligence. With the so called argumentation frameworks (AFs) it is possible to represent statements (arguments) together with a binary attack relation between them. The conflicts between the statements are solved on a semantical level by selecting acceptable s...
متن کاملArgo-Graph: Using Graph for Learning in Physics Labwork
Argo-Graph is a collaborative software supporting the co-construction of a shared representation of a scientific argumentation used for labwork in Physics. This is a support for student’s comprehension of a scientific phenomenon. We present the tool specifications and first elements of its evaluation. 1. Theoretical approaches Our work has its foundations in two domains, collaborative learning ...
متن کاملArgumentation Machines: New Frontiers in Argumentation and Computation edited by Chris ReedTimothy J. Norman
Argumentation may be defined as the study of different aspects of (human) interactions whose objective is to reach a conclusion about the truth of a proposition or the adoption of a course of action. The aspects in question include the argu-mentation interaction, which is typically a dialogue; the construction and presentation of arguments for or against a proposition; the interpretation of arg...
متن کاملChecking Conditions for Graph Based Collaborative Modeling Systems
Cooperative systems with a special focus on enabling sharing and commenting of resources and material are a prominent subject in the research area of computer technology in education. The representation mode of these shared resources plays an important role for the learning process [1]. One frequently used mode is a graph based notation in which a shared visual representation consists of object...
متن کامل